6 Best Alternatives to the New Star Foodservice 1028614 Commercial Grade Cast (2026)

Comparing cast iron alternatives

Utopia Kitchen 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

The Utopia Kitchen 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet offers a significantly larger cooking surface than the New Star Foodservice 1028614. Measuring 12 inches across, it provides more room for large family meals or outdoor cooking compared to the 10-by-7-inch oval pan. It weighs 7.58 pounds, making it much heavier and less portable than the lightweight New Star set. Both are pre-seasoned cast iron, but the Utopia skillet is PFAS-free. You should choose this option if you prioritize a spacious, versatile pan for general skillet tasks over the specialized serving experience of a fajita set. It lacks the included wood base and mitt, focusing purely on cooking performance.

Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan

The Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan differs by featuring a ribbed surface designed for searing steaks and creating grill marks. Unlike the smooth oval skillet of the New Star Foodservice, this square pan measures 10.5 inches and weighs 6.5 pounds. It is PFAS-free and built for durability across various heat sources. You would pick this alternative if your goal is to achieve professional-grade sear marks on meats rather than serving sizzling fajitas. It sacrifices the unique oval shape and included serving accessories of the original. The Lodge pan is a dedicated grilling tool, offering a different cooking texture and visual appeal for your main courses.

Victoria Oval Cast Iron Fajita Skillet

The Victoria Oval Cast Iron Fajita Skillet closely mirrors the New Star Foodservice 1028614 in shape and purpose. It is an oval pan suitable for large fajita servings, particularly on induction stoves. The Victoria model measures 16.3 inches by 7 inches, offering a wide, flat cooking surface. It weighs less than the New Star set, which lists 5 ounces for the complete set including accessories. Both are black cast iron, but the Victoria skillet focuses on the pan alone without a wood base or mitt. You should select this if you need a wide surface for induction compatibility and prefer a standalone pan. It provides similar heat retention without the extra serving components.

Guidesman 22-Inch Cast Iron Camp Grill Cooker

The Guidesman 22-Inch Cast Iron Camp Grill Cooker is designed for outdoor use, featuring a long 28-inch handle to protect you from flames. This is a stark contrast to the indoor-focused New Star Foodservice set. It weighs only 1 pound and is made for campfire grilling. The cooking surface is 22 inches wide, providing ample space for outdoor meals. You would choose this alternative if you prioritize heat distance and durability for camping trips. It lacks the pre-seasoned indoor-ready surface and serving accessories of the New Star pan. This tool is built for rugged outdoor environments, offering a different cooking experience entirely focused on open-fire grilling rather than tableside sizzling.

Granite Ware 19-Inch Oval Roaster

The Granite Ware 19-Inch Oval Roaster is made from speckled black granite enamel, not cast iron. It measures 19.1 inches long and weighs 3.5 pounds. This roaster is designed for large family roasts and holiday poultry in the oven. Unlike the New Star Foodservice skillet, which is for stovetop sizzling, this pan is for oven roasting. You should pick this if you regularly cook large poultry or roasts. It offers high capacity and a durable enamel surface. It lacks the heat retention and sizzling effect of cast iron. This alternative is a practical staple for oven cooking, providing a different material and cooking method for your kitchen needs.

OzawaBear 11-Inch Titanium Nonstick Skillet

The OzawaBear 11-Inch Titanium Nonstick Skillet uses a titanium-reinforced nonstick surface, differing from the cast iron of the New Star Foodservice. It measures 11 inches and weighs significantly less. The pan is PFAS-free and designed for daily frying and sautéing. It offers easy cleaning and stovetop versatility. You would choose this if you prioritize a lightweight, easy-to-clean surface over the heavy heat retention of cast iron. It lacks the oval shape and serving accessories of the original. This skillet is practical for everyday cooking tasks where quick cleanup and even heating are more important than the traditional sizzling presentation of a fajita set.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

New Star Foodservice 10 x 7-Inch Oval Cast Iron Pan

Best for: sizzling fajitas and steak plates

Body Material

Cast iron

Cooking Surface

Preseasoned cast iron

Dishwasher Safe

Hand wash only

Color

Black

Shape

Oval

Dimensions

15 × 10.6 × 7.5 inches

View on Amazon: New Star Foodservice 10 x 7-Inch Oval Cast Iron Pan Affiliate link

This commercial-grade set includes a 10-by-7-inch oval cast iron skillet, a walnut-stained wood base, and a chili-pepper handle mitt. The preseasoned surface conducts heat well and becomes more stick-resistant with use. It is designed for high-volume environments but works in home kitchens. You need to hand wash it to maintain the surface quality. The set measures 15 inches in length and weighs 5 ounces.

Pros

• Includes 10-by-7-inch oval cast iron skillet
• Comes with walnut-stained wood base for serving
• Preseasoned cooking surface for reduced sticking
• Decorative chili-pepper handle mitt for heat protection

Cons

• Requires hand washing only, not dishwasher safe
• Heavier build than standard non-stick pans
• Limited to fajita and sizzling plate applications

Good fit if

• You want a complete commercial-grade serving set
• You prefer the heat retention of cast iron
• You need a skillet for sizzling fajitas

Skip if

• You need dishwasher-safe cookware
• You prefer a round skillet shape
• You want a lightweight aluminum pan

Verdict: New Star Foodservice Oval Cast Iron Fajita Set is a durable option for professionals or home cooks who value the authentic sizzle and heat retention of cast iron for fajitas and steak plates.

2 Best pre-seasoned

Utopia Kitchen 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

Best for: Large family meals and outdoor cooking

Body Material

Cast iron

Cooking Surface

Pre-seasoned with vegetable oil

Pan Diameter

12 inches

Cooktop Compatibility

Stovetop, campfire, grill

Material Feature

PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned

Color

Black

View on Amazon: Utopia Kitchen 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet Affiliate link

This Utopia Kitchen skillet offers a 12-inch cooking surface made from cast iron. It measures 2.2 inches in height and weighs 7.58 pounds. The pan is pre-seasoned with vegetable oil and is PFAS-free. You can use it on stovetops, camping gear, or grills. The large diameter provides ample space for family meals. It is a versatile option for searing and frying.

Pros

• 12-inch diameter provides ample cooking space
• Pre-seasoned with vegetable oil for immediate use
• PFAS-free construction
• Compatible with stovetops, grills, and camping setups

Cons

• Heavy at 7.58 pounds
• Single skillet sold without a wooden base or serving stand
• No helper handle included for two-handed lifting

Good fit if

• You need a large 12-inch surface for family meals
• You want a PFAS-free cooking surface
• You cook on stovetops, grills, or while camping

Skip if

• You prefer lighter cookware for easy handling
• You need a complete fajita set with a wooden base
• You want a smaller 10.25-inch option

Verdict: Utopia Kitchen 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet is a solid choice for cooks who prioritize a large, PFAS-free cooking surface and versatile heat source compatibility over portability or included serving accessories.

3 Also great

Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan

Best for: Searing steaks with grill marks

Body Material

Cast iron

Cooking Surface

Seasoned cast iron

Pan Diameter

10.5 inches

Cooktop Compatibility

Stovetops

Material Feature

PFAS-Free, Non-Toxic

Color

Black

View on Amazon: Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan Affiliate link

The Lodge Square Cast Iron Grill Pan is a PFAS-free cooking tool designed for high-heat searing. Its 10.5-inch square surface channels excess grease away while delivering bold grill marks. The pan features traditionally crafted seasoned cast iron for even heat distribution. It works on stovetops, in ovens, on grills, and over campfires. This versatile pan suits those who want steakhouse results at home without chemical coatings.

Pros

• PFAS-free seasoned cast iron surface
• Square design channels excess grease
• Compatible with stovetops, ovens, grills, and campfires
• Promotes even heat distribution

Cons

• 10.5-inch cooking surface is smaller than many round skillets
• Square shape may not fit all round burners perfectly
• Cast iron construction is heavy and requires seasoning maintenance

Good fit if

• You want to sear steaks with distinct grill marks
• You prefer PFAS-free cookware for indoor or outdoor use
• You need a pan that works on multiple heat sources

Skip if

• You prefer lightweight aluminum or stainless steel pans
• You need a large round surface for wide pans
• You want non-stick cookware that requires no seasoning

Verdict: Lodge 10.5-Inch Square Cast Iron Grill Pan is a durable, chemical-free option for searing meats. It fits buyers who value traditional cast iron performance across various heat sources.

4 Best budget

Victoria Oval Cast Iron Fajita Skillet

Best for: large fajita servings on induction stoves

Body Material

Cast iron

Cooktop Compatibility

Induction, gas, ceramic, electric

Color

Black

Shape

Oval

Dimensions

7 × 16.3 × 1.5 inches

View on Amazon: Victoria Oval Cast Iron Fajita Skillet Affiliate link

The Victoria oval skillet measures 16.3 inches long and 7 inches wide with a 1.5-inch height. It is made of cast iron and features a textured surface seasoned with flaxseed oil. This design offers excellent heat retention and prevents warping. It works on induction, gas, ceramic, and electric stovetops. The long handle provides leverage for easy handling. You will appreciate its durable construction for serving or cooking.

Pros

• Oval shape measures 16.3 inches by 7 inches
• Textured surface retains seasoning better than smooth pans
• Compatible with induction, gas, ceramic, and electric cooktops
• Long ergonomic handle improves leverage and handling

Cons

• Oval shape may not fit all standard burner sizes
• Heavy cast iron construction requires careful handling
• No lid included in the package

Good fit if

• You want a large surface area for fajitas
• You need a skillet that works on induction stoves
• You prefer a textured surface for better seasoning

Skip if

• You need a round skillet for even burner contact
• You want a lightweight pan for easy tossing
• You require a lid for braising or steaming

Verdict: Victoria Oval Cast Iron Fajita Skillet is a solid choice for those who need a wide, flat cooking surface that works on modern induction stoves. It suits you if you prioritize heat retention and a textured surface for seasoning durability over a traditional round shape.

5 Best premium

Guidesman 22-Inch Cast Iron Camp Grill Cooker

Best for: campfire grilling and outdoor cooking

Body Material

Cast iron

Color

Black

Use

Camping

Recommended Use

Grilling

Dimensions

28 × 4 × 2 inches

Weight

1 pounds

View on Amazon: Guidesman 22-Inch Cast Iron Camp Grill Cooker Affiliate link

This Guidesman cast iron camp grill features a 22-inch cooking surface and a 28-inch total length. The extra-long handle keeps you safe from heat. It weighs 1 pound and is designed for grilling outdoors. The wooden handle includes a leather string for storage. You will find this tool practical for campfire cooking and outdoor gatherings where space and safety matter.

Pros

• 22-inch cast iron cooking surface
• 28-inch total length with extra-long handle
• Wooden handle with leather storage string
• Lightweight at 1 pound

Cons

• Requires manual cleaning and seasoning
• Single function limited to grilling
• Heavy cast iron construction

Good fit if

• You need a long handle for campfire safety
• You prefer traditional cast iron cookware
• You cook outdoors over open flames

Skip if

• You want a non-stick surface
• You need indoor kitchen use
• You prefer lightweight aluminum pans

Verdict: Guidesman 22 Inch Cast Iron Camp Grill suits campers who prioritize heat distance and durability. Its long handle protects you from flames while the cast iron retains heat for consistent grilling.

6 Best granite

Granite Ware 19-Inch Oval Roaster

Best for: Large family roasts and holiday poultry

Body Material

Enamel on steel

Cooking Surface

Porcelain enamel

Color

Black

Use

Roasting

Recommended Use

Grilling

Shape

Oval

View on Amazon: Granite Ware 19-Inch Oval Roaster Affiliate link

This covered oval roaster offers a 20 lb capacity for large poultry or roasts. The 19-inch length fits standard oven racks. Its dark porcelain enamel surface absorbs heat efficiently for even browning. The steel construction resists chipping and scratching. You get a non-toxic cooking surface free from PFOA and PTFE. The lid doubles as a second roaster. This setup suits families needing versatile, durable oven cookware for regular use.

Pros

• 20 lb capacity handles large cuts of meat
• 19-inch length fits most standard ovens
• Dark porcelain enamel absorbs heat for even browning
• Steel construction resists chipping and scratching
• Non-toxic surface free from PFOA and PTFE

Cons

• Heavier at 3.5 pounds than cast iron alternatives
• Limited to oven use; cannot go on stovetop
• Enamel surface requires hand washing to preserve finish

Good fit if

• You need a large capacity for holiday meals
• You prefer non-toxic cooking surfaces
• You want versatile oven cookware that doubles as serving ware

Skip if

• You require stovetop compatibility
• You prefer lightweight aluminum cookware
• You need a smaller 13-inch size

Verdict: Granite Ware 20 Lb Speckled Black Roaster fits households cooking large poultry regularly. Its durable enamel surface and high capacity make it a practical staple for oven roasting.

7 Best nonstick

OzawaBear 11-Inch Titanium Nonstick Skillet

Best for: PFAS-free daily frying and sautéing

Body Material

Aluminum

Cooking Surface

Titanium nonstick

Pan Diameter

11 Inch

Cooktop Compatibility

All stovetops, including induction

Material Feature

PTFE-Free

Color

Black

View on Amazon: OzawaBear 11-Inch Titanium Nonstick Skillet Affiliate link

The OzawaBear 11 Inch Frying Pan uses an aluminum body with a double-sided titanium nonstick coating. It is free of Teflon, PFAS, lead, and cadmium. The stainless steel base works on induction, gas, electric, and ceramic stoves. You get even heating and easy cleaning. This pan suits those who want a versatile, healthy cooking surface for daily meals.

Pros

• Double-sided titanium nonstick coating
• Free of Teflon, PFAS, lead, and cadmium
• Compatible with induction, gas, electric, and ceramic stoves
• Aluminum body for even heating

Cons

• Aluminum body may not last as long as cast iron
• Titanium coating requires careful handling to avoid scratches
• No lid included for versatile cooking

Good fit if

• You want a nonstick pan free of PFAS and Teflon
• You need a pan that works on all stovetops
• You prefer easy cleaning with just a wipe or rinse

Skip if

• You prefer cast iron for its durability and heat retention
• You need a pan with a lid for braising or steaming
• You want a pan that can go from stovetop to oven

Verdict: OzawaBear 11 Inch Titanium Nonstick Pan is a practical choice for those who prioritize a PFAS-free, easy-to-clean surface and stovetop versatility. It fits well in kitchens where daily frying and sautéing are common.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions