Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron vs Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square (2026): Key Differences
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
This guide compares the Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle against the Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle. We examine the lodge round seasoned cast iron vs pre seasoned cast iron square options to help you decide. Both items are made from durable cast iron and come pre-seasoned with vegetable oil for immediate use. They share a black finish and are free from PFAS, PFOA, and PTFE. The main difference lies in their shape and size, which affects cooking surface area and heat distribution.
Key differences
| Aspect | Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle | Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle |
|---|---|---|
| Shape | Round | Square |
| Dimensions | 10.5 inches wide, 15.9 inches long | 11 inches wide, 17.3 inches long |
| Height | 1.5 inches | 1.81 inches |
| Weight | 4.51 pounds | 5.9 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle if
- You prefer a lighter pan that is easier to handle and store.
- You want a round cooking surface for traditional items like tortillas or pancakes.
Choose Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle if
- You need a larger cooking surface for batch cooking or family meals.
- You want a deeper pan with higher sides to contain splatters.
Verdict: The round griddle is the better choice if you prioritize manageability and a classic shape. The square griddle suits those who need maximum surface area and deeper sides for versatile cooking. Both offer durable, chemical-free cast iron performance.
Round vs Square Cast Iron Griddle
Shape and Surface
The Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle features a circular cooking surface, while the Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle offers a rectangular footprint. The round design provides a continuous edge, which can be useful for rolling items like tortillas. The square shape maximizes corner space, allowing you to fit more rectangular items like steaks or multiple pancakes simultaneously. Both shapes are designed for even heat distribution, but the square model provides a larger total cooking area due to its 11-inch width compared to the 10.5-inch diameter of the round version. You should choose based on whether you prefer circular symmetry or maximum rectangular surface area.
Dimensions and Weight
Size and weight differ noticeably between these two griddles. The round model measures 10.6 inches in width, 15.9 inches in length, and stands 1.5 inches high, weighing 4.51 pounds. The square model is larger, with dimensions of 11 inches by 17.3 inches and a height of 1.81 inches, weighing 5.9 pounds. The square griddle is significantly heavier and taller, which may affect storage in tight cabinets or handling during flipping. The round griddle is lighter and more compact, making it easier to maneuver for one person. Consider your stovetop burner size and storage space when deciding between the lighter round option and the heavier, larger square option.
Material and Finish
Both griddles are constructed from durable cast iron and come pre-seasoned with vegetable oil, creating a natural non-stick surface that improves with use. They are both PFAS-free, PFOA-free, and PTFE-free, ensuring a non-toxic cooking environment. The Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle is explicitly described as having a traditionally crafted non-toxic finish made with only iron and oil. Similarly, the Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle is crafted from heirloom-quality cast iron with a seasoned finish. Neither product includes additional chemical coatings, relying on the seasoned iron layer for performance. You get the same safe, chemical-free material foundation in either choice.
Cooktop Compatibility
Both griddles are versatile and compatible with a wide range of heat sources. You can use either the Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle or the Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle on standard stovetops, in ovens, on grills, and over campfires. This compatibility makes them suitable for indoor kitchen meals as well as outdoor camping trips. The square model is specifically noted as campfire ready, but the round model also supports seamless cooking from kitchen to outdoors. Since both are made of cast iron, they retain heat well and distribute it evenly across their respective surfaces. You can confidently use either pan on any heat source you typically employ.
Color and Aesthetics
Both griddles share a classic black color, which is typical for seasoned cast iron cookware. The Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle is listed as black, matching the visual style of the Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle. This uniform color helps them blend into most kitchen aesthetics or look authentic on a campfire. The black finish comes from the seasoning process rather than a painted coating, so it may vary slightly in shade depending on use and care. Since both products offer the same traditional black appearance, your choice will depend on shape preference rather than visual style. You can match either griddle to existing black cast iron sets without conflict.
Which Lodge Griddle Suits Your Needs
You want maximum surface area for large batches
The 11-Inch Square Griddle offers a larger footprint with dimensions of 17.3 by 11 inches. This extra space accommodates more pancakes, eggs, or tortillas at once. Its rectangular shape fits standard stovetop burners well. The cast iron construction ensures even heat distribution across the wider surface for consistent cooking results.
You prefer a lighter pan for easier handling
The 10.5-Inch Round Griddle weighs 4.51 pounds, making it significantly lighter than the square version. This reduced weight simplifies lifting, flipping, and storage. The circular shape provides a continuous edge that helps contain juices. It remains versatile for indoor and outdoor use while being easier to manage during daily meal prep.
You need a compact griddle for smaller kitchens
With a diameter of 10.5 inches, the round griddle takes up less counter and storage space. Its lower profile and lighter weight make it ideal for small apartments or dorm rooms. The pre-seasoned surface is ready to use immediately. It works well on stovetops, ovens, and camp stoves without requiring extensive storage area.
The products compared
Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle
Best for: Even heating and traditional round cooking
- Body Material
- Cast iron
- Interior Coating
- Pre-seasoned
- Coating Safety Claims
- PFOA, PTFE, and PFAS-free
- Material Feature
- PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned, Non-Toxic
- Color
- Black
- Use
- Camping
View on Amazon: Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle Affiliate link
This Lodge griddle is a 10.5-inch round cast iron pan designed for even heat distribution. It comes pre-seasoned with a natural oil finish, making it ready to use for tortillas or pancakes right out of the box. The PFAS-free construction ensures safe cooking. Weighing 4.51 pounds, it offers durability for both indoor stovetop and outdoor grill use. You will appreciate its traditional craftsmanship and versatile compatibility with various heat sources.
Pros
- Pre-seasoned with natural oil for immediate use
- Round shape promotes even heat distribution
- PFAS-free, PFOA-free, and PTFE-free materials
- Compatible with stovetops, ovens, grills, and camp stoves
Cons
- Heavy at 4.51 pounds, making it less portable than lighter options
- Round shape offers less surface area for flat items compared to square griddles
- Requires hand washing to maintain the seasoned coating
Good fit if
- You prefer the even heating properties of round cookware
- You want a pre-seasoned pan ready for immediate use
- You cook for smaller families or couples
Skip if
- You need maximum surface area for large batches of food
- You prefer lightweight cookware for easy handling
- You want a square shape for better edge-to-edge cooking
Verdict: Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle is a solid choice for cooks who value traditional round heat distribution and pre-seasoned convenience. It fits those who prioritize even cooking over maximum surface area.
Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle
Best for: cooking flat foods on square burners
- Body Material
- Cast iron
- Interior Coating
- Seasoned cast iron
- Coating Safety Claims
- PFAS-Free
- Material Feature
- PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned, Non-Toxic
- Color
- Black
- Recommended Use
- Grilling
View on Amazon: Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle Affiliate link
This Lodge pre-seasoned square griddle measures 17.3 by 11 inches. It is made from heavy cast iron that is PFAS-free. The pan weighs 5.9 pounds and stands 1.81 inches high. You can use it in the oven, on the stove, or over a campfire. The square shape fits well on flat burners. It is a durable option for cooking pancakes, eggs, and tortillas.
Pros
- PFAS-free seasoned surface
- Square shape maximizes burner space
- Oven and campfire safe
- Durable cast iron construction
Cons
- Heavy at 5.9 pounds
- Square shape does not fit round burners
- Requires hand washing
Good fit if
- You want a flat surface for pancakes
- You have a square or rectangular burner
- You cook for a family
Skip if
- You need a lightweight pan
- You only have round burners
- You want dishwasher safe cookware
Verdict: Lodge 11-Inch Square Cast Iron Griddle is a sturdy choice for those with square burners who want a flat cooking surface. It fits well in kitchens where you cook breakfast items often.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle | Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle |
|---|---|---|
| Body Material | Cast iron | Cast iron |
| Interior Coating | Pre-seasoned | Seasoned cast iron |
| Coating Safety Claims | PFOA, PTFE, and PFAS-free | PFAS-Free |
| Material | Cast Iron | Cast Iron |
| Material Feature | PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned, Non-Toxic | PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned, Non-Toxic |
| Color | Black | Black |
| Use | Camping | not stated |
| Recommended Use | Grilling | Grilling |
| Shape | Round | not stated |
| Dimensions | 15.9 × 10.6 × 1.5 inches | 17.3 × 11 × 1.81 inches |
| Weight | 4.65 pounds | 5.9 pounds |
| Size | 10.5 Inch (Pack of 1) | 11" |
| Model | Lodge Cast Iron Rectangular Griddle | L9SGR |
Frequently asked questions
Is the Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Griddle pre-seasoned?
Yes, the Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle comes pre-seasoned. This feature means it is ready to use right out of the box. The seasoning layer is PFAS-free, providing a natural non-stick surface. You can start cooking immediately without needing to apply your own initial seasoning layer.
Does the Lodge 11-Inch Square Griddle have a handle?
The product data does not specify handle details for the Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle. It lists the weight as 5.9 pounds and dimensions of 17.3 by 11 inches. You should consult the manufacturer’s manual or product images for specific handle configuration and heat-resistant features.
Which griddle is heavier, the round or square Lodge?
The Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle is heavier. It weighs 5.9 pounds, while the Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle weighs 4.51 pounds. The square version is also taller at 1.81 inches compared to the round one’s 1.5 inches. This extra mass may help with heat retention.
Are both Lodge griddles made of cast iron?
Yes, both products are constructed from cast iron. The Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Griddle is made of cast iron and is black in color. Similarly, the Lodge 11-Inch Square Griddle is also black cast iron. Cast iron provides durable heat distribution and long-lasting performance for various cooking tasks.
What are the dimensions of the Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Griddle?
The Lodge 10.5-Inch Round Cast Iron Griddle measures 15.9 inches in length and 10.6 inches in width. Its height is 1.5 inches. Despite the name suggesting a 10.5-inch diameter, the physical dimensions are rectangular in the data provided. The total weight is 4.51 pounds.
Is the Lodge 11-Inch Square Griddle suitable for square burners?
Yes, the Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle is designed for cooking on square burners. Its rectangular shape, measuring 17.3 by 11 inches, fits well on such surfaces. This makes it a sturdy choice for preparing flat foods like breakfast items efficiently on compatible stove tops.
Do these griddles contain PTFE or PFAS?
No, neither griddle contains PFAS. Both the Lodge 10.5-Inch Round and the Lodge 11-Inch Square models are listed as PFAS-free. They also come pre-seasoned, which typically uses plant-based oils. This ensures a safe cooking surface free from specific synthetic chemicals often found in non-stick coatings.