Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle or Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square? Which Lodge Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Choosing between the lodge pre seasoned cast iron griddle vs 11 inch cast iron square depends on your cooking space. Both items are made from pre-seasoned cast iron that distributes heat evenly. They share a traditional, PFAS-free finish using only iron and vegetable oil. The main difference lies in their shape and dimensions. One offers a rectangular surface with a red handle holder, while the other provides a square design with deeper sides. Your choice should match your stove size and cooking habits.
Key differences
| Aspect | Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle | Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle |
|---|---|---|
| Shape and Dimensions | Rectangular, 15.9 x 10.6 inches | Square, 17.3 x 11 inches |
| Height | 1.5 inches | 1.81 inches |
| Weight | 4.51 pounds | 5.9 pounds |
| Handle Feature | Includes red silicone handle holder | Not listed |
| Color | Black/Red | Black |
| Model Number | Lodge Cast Iron Rectangular Griddle | L9SGR |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle if
- You prefer a lighter pan that is easier to lift and maneuver
- You want a silicone handle holder for a safer, more comfortable grip
- You need a rectangular shape that fits standard stovetop burners
Choose Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle if
- You want deeper sides to contain splatters or liquids
- You need a larger total surface area for cooking multiple items
- You prefer a square shape for arranging food in a grid
Verdict: Choose the rectangular griddle if you value lighter weight and a dedicated handle holder for comfort. Opt for the square model if you need deeper sides and a larger footprint for bigger batches. Both provide durable, pre-seasoned surfaces for consistent cooking.
Lodge Griddle vs Square Comparison
Cooking Surface Size
The Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle measures 10.6 inches in width and 15.9 inches in length. This provides a solid rectangular area for breakfast items like pancakes or eggs. The Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle is slightly larger at 11 inches wide and 17.3 inches long. The extra length on the square model gives you more room for larger tortillas or multiple sandwiches. If you need maximum surface area for a family meal, the larger square griddle offers more space. The smaller rectangular griddle is more compact for smaller stovetops.
Weight and Portability
Cast iron is inherently heavy, but these two models differ in mass. The Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle weighs 4.51 pounds. This lighter weight makes it easier to lift and move around the kitchen, especially if you are cooking over a campfire or moving it to the oven. The Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle weighs 5.9 pounds. The additional pound of iron helps it retain heat longer once it is hot. If you prefer lighter cookware for easier handling, the rectangular griddle is the better choice. The square model requires more strength to maneuver.
Handle Design
The handle design affects how safely you can hold the pan. The Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle includes a red silicone handle holder. This accessory provides a safer and more comfortable grip compared to bare cast iron. It protects your hand from the heat of the metal handle. The Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle data does not list a specific handle accessory or holder. It relies on the standard cast iron handle design. If you want extra protection and comfort while holding the pan, the rectangular griddle with its silicone holder is the superior option for everyday use.
Height and Depth
The height of the griddle walls can matter for certain cooking tasks. The Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle has a height of 1.5 inches. This lower profile is good for flipping items like burgers or eggs without them hitting high walls. The Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle stands taller at 1.81 inches. The deeper sides might help contain splatters or hold juices for certain recipes. For most flat-top cooking like pancakes, the lower profile of the rectangular griddle is often preferred. The square model is taller, which may limit what fits under low-hanging cabinets.
Material and Finish
Both products share the same core material and finish. They are made from pre-seasoned cast iron using only iron and vegetable oil. Both are PFAS-free, ensuring a non-toxic cooking surface. The Lodge 10.5-Inch model is described as having a traditionally crafted non-toxic finish. The Lodge 11-Inch model also features this same traditional, chemical-free seasoning. There is no difference in the safety or composition of the cooking surface between the two. Both will develop a natural non-stick patina over time with proper care. You can choose either model based on size and weight preferences without compromising on material quality.
Which Lodge Griddle Fits Your Kitchen
Small kitchen cooks with limited counter space
You should choose the 10.5-Inch Griddle if your stovetop or storage is tight. Its 15.9-inch length and 4.51-pound weight make it easier to handle and store than the larger alternative. The included red silicone handle holder adds a comfortable grip for safer maneuvering when cooking smaller batches of food.
Families needing extra cooking area for breakfast
The 11-Inch Square Griddle offers a wider 17.3-inch length and 11-inch width for cooking more pancakes or eggs at once. This larger surface accommodates bigger meals efficiently. Although it weighs 5.9 pounds, the extra capacity justifies the size for households preparing substantial daily breakfasts or large gatherings.
Campers and outdoor cooking enthusiasts
This square model is explicitly noted as campfire ready, making it ideal for outdoor use. Its durable cast iron construction resists warping over open flames. The larger dimensions allow for versatile cooking on grills or stoves, ensuring you can prepare hearty meals reliably wherever your travels take you.
The products compared
Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle
Best for: small kitchens and solo cooking
- Body Material
- Cast iron
- Interior Coating
- Vegetable oil
- Coating Safety Claims
- PFAS-free
- Handle Material
- Silicone
- Material Feature
- Pre-Seasoned
- Dimensions
- 15.9 × 10.6 × 1.5 inches
View on Amazon: Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle Affiliate link
This Lodge griddle measures 10.5 inches wide and 15.9 inches long. It weighs 4.51 pounds and features a pre-seasoned cast iron surface. The included red silicone handle holder provides a safer grip. The flat design supports even heat distribution for consistent cooking results. It suits you if you need a compact surface for breakfast items or sandwiches.
Pros
- Pre-seasoned cast iron surface
- Red silicone handle holder included
- Even heat distribution
- PFAS-free construction
Cons
- Narrower 10.5-inch width
- Heavier 4.51-pound build
- Requires hand washing
Good fit if
- You cook for one or two people
- You have limited stovetop space
- You prefer a compact griddle
Skip if
- You need to cook for a large family
- You want a lightweight pan
- You prefer a square shape
Verdict: Lodge 10.5-Inch Cast Iron Griddle fits small kitchens or solo cooks who value a compact, durable surface. It is not ideal for large batches or those seeking a square shape.
Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle
Best for: large family breakfasts and versatile cooking
- Body Material
- Cast iron
- Interior Coating
- Seasoned cast iron
- Coating Safety Claims
- PFAS-Free
- Material Feature
- PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned, Non-Toxic
- Color
- Black
- Recommended Use
- Grilling
View on Amazon: Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle Affiliate link
This Lodge square griddle measures 17.3 inches by 11 inches with 1.81-inch sides. Weighing 5.9 pounds, it is made from durable cast iron. The surface is pre-seasoned with vegetable oil and is PFAS-free. You can use it on the stove, in the oven, or over a campfire. The flat design helps cook pancakes, eggs, and tortillas evenly. It fits well if you need a large, stable cooking surface for family meals.
Pros
- Generous 17.3-inch by 11-inch cooking surface
- Pre-seasoned with vegetable oil for immediate use
- PFAS-free interior coating
- Compatible with all heat sources including campfires
Cons
- Heavy at 5.9 pounds
- Square shape may not fit all round burners
- Requires hand washing to maintain seasoning
Good fit if
- You cook for a family and need extra surface area
- You want a versatile pan for stovetop and oven use
- You prefer PFAS-free cookware
Skip if
- You need lightweight cookware for easy handling
- You only have small round burners
- You want dishwasher-safe convenience
Verdict: Lodge 11-Inch Square Cast Iron Griddle offers a large, durable cooking surface for families. It is best for those who prioritize even heat distribution and versatile cooking methods over lightweight convenience.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle | Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle |
|---|---|---|
| Body Material | Cast iron | Cast iron |
| Interior Coating | Vegetable oil | Seasoned cast iron |
| Coating Safety Claims | PFAS-free | PFAS-Free |
| Handle Material | Silicone | not stated |
| Material | Cast Iron | Cast Iron |
| Material Feature | Pre-Seasoned | PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned, Non-Toxic |
| Color | Black/Red | Black |
| Recommended Use | not stated | Grilling |
| Dimensions | 15.9 × 10.6 × 1.5 inches | 17.3 × 11 × 1.81 inches |
| Weight | 4.51 pounds | 5.9 pounds |
| Size | 10.5 Inch | 11" |
| Model | Lodge Cast Iron Rectangular Griddle | L9SGR |
Frequently asked questions
Is the Lodge 10.5-inch griddle better for small kitchens?
Yes, the Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle is ideal for small kitchens. It measures 15.9 inches in length and weighs only 4.51 pounds. This compact size and lighter weight make it easier to store and handle than larger alternatives. It fits well on smaller stovetops and in tight storage spaces.
Does the 11-inch square griddle work for large families?
Yes, the Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle is best for large family breakfasts. It offers a larger cooking surface with dimensions of 17.3 inches by 11 inches. This extra space allows you to cook more items at once, making it suitable for versatile cooking methods and feeding more people simultaneously.
Are both Lodge griddles made from the same material?
Yes, both models are made from cast iron. The 10.5-inch version features a pre-seasoned finish, while the 11-inch square model is also pre-seasoned and PFAS-free. Both use traditional finishes with iron and vegetable oil. This material ensures durable, even heat distribution for consistent cooking results across both products.
Which griddle is lighter and easier to handle?
The Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle is lighter. It weighs 4.51 pounds, compared to the 11-inch square griddle, which weighs 5.9 pounds. The lower weight makes the smaller model easier to lift, move, and clean. If you prioritize lightweight convenience over maximum surface area, the 10.5-inch option is the better choice.
Can I use the square griddle for versatile cooking?
Yes, the Lodge 11-Inch Cast Iron Square Griddle supports versatile cooking. Its square shape and larger surface area accommodate various cooking methods beyond just breakfast. It provides a durable surface that handles even heat distribution well. This makes it a practical tool for preparing diverse meals that require ample space.
Does the 10.5-inch griddle fit solo cooks?
Yes, the Lodge 10.5-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle is designed for solo cooks. Its compact dimensions and 4.51-pound weight suit individuals who value a durable but manageable surface. It is not ideal for large batches, but it perfectly serves those who cook for one or two people in a small kitchen.