6-Piece vs 5-Piece Skillets: Which Should You Buy?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are comparing a 6-Piece vs 5-Piece skillet set to decide which cast iron collection fits your kitchen. Both options from Asderote and Lodge are made of pre-seasoned cast iron and are PFAS-free. They share similar core materials and cooking surfaces. The main difference lies in the number of pieces included in each set. You also need to consider the total weight and specific dimensions of each package. This guide breaks down the specs to help you choose.
Key differences
| Aspect | Asderote 6-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set | Lodge 5-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set |
|---|---|---|
| Number of Pieces | 6 | 5 |
| Weight | 32 pounds | 28 pounds |
| Width | 12.8 inches | 14.2 inches |
| Height | 6.3 inches | 7.9 inches |
| Length | 22.6 inches | 15 inches |
| Oven Safe | Up to 500°F | not listed |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Asderote 6-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set if
- You want a larger set that includes a square grill pan and a cover for the dutch oven.
- You prefer a lighter overall footprint with a shorter height for easier stacking and storage.
- You need explicit oven safety ratings listed in the specifications.
Choose Lodge 5-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set if
- You prefer a lighter set that weighs 28 pounds instead of 32 pounds.
- You want a more compact package with a shorter length for smaller cabinets.
- You trust the established Lodge brand reputation for traditional cast iron quality.
Verdict: The Asderote set offers more pieces and a lower profile, making it better for those who want variety and easier storage. The Lodge set is lighter and more compact, which suits cooks who prioritize weight and brand heritage. Choose the one that matches your storage space and piece count needs.
6-Piece vs 5-Piece Cast Iron Comparison
Number of Pieces
The Asderote set includes six pieces, while the Lodge set contains five. Asderote adds a square cast iron grill pan to the mix. This extra item allows you to grill vegetables or proteins with distinct sear marks. Lodge sticks to the core essentials: two skillets, a griddle, and a dutch oven. If you frequently cook foods that benefit from a flat griddle surface or a dedicated grill pan, the sixth piece in the Asderote collection provides more versatility. Lodge offers a more streamlined collection for those who prefer a simpler setup with fewer items to manage in the kitchen.
Weight and Storage
Weight matters for handling and storage. The Asderote 6-Piece set weighs 32 pounds. The Lodge 5-Piece set weighs 28 pounds. The extra four pounds in the Asderote set come from the additional square grill pan. Cast iron is inherently heavy, so this difference is noticeable. If you have limited cabinet space, the Lodge set is slightly lighter and easier to lift. However, Asderote notes that its pans are stackable, which can save up to 75% of kitchen storage space. This stacking feature helps mitigate the bulk of the extra piece. You should consider how much counter or cabinet space you have available for your cast iron collection.
Oven Compatibility
Both sets are made of cast iron, which is known for high heat tolerance. The Asderote set is oven-safe up to 500°F. The Lodge set data does not explicitly list an oven-safe temperature limit in the provided specifications. Cast iron generally handles high heat well, but without a specific number from Lodge, you cannot be certain of the exact limit. Asderote provides a clear 500°F rating, giving you a defined boundary for baking or broiling. This clarity helps you plan recipes that require high-temperature oven finishing without guessing. Always check the manufacturer guidelines before exceeding safe temperature limits for your specific cookware.
Material Feature
Health and safety are key concerns for many buyers. Both the Asderote and Lodge sets are PFAS-free and pre-seasoned. Asderote specifies that it uses only iron and 100% natural vegetable oil for its seasoning. Lodge also states it is made with only iron and oil, delivering a PFAS-free finish. Neither set contains PFOA, PTFE, or synthetic coatings. This means you avoid toxic chemicals and worry less about coating peeling off onto your food. Both brands offer a durable, nonstick surface created through traditional seasoning. You can choose either brand with confidence regarding the absence of harmful synthetic materials in your cooking surface.
Included Skillet Sizes
Skillet size affects what you can cook. Both sets include an 8-inch skillet and a 10.25-inch skillet. Asderote also includes a 10.5-inch round griddle. Lodge includes a 10.5-inch cast iron griddle as well. The core frying surfaces are identical in size between the two collections. This similarity means you have the same options for searing steaks or frying eggs regardless of your choice. The difference lies in the additional square grill pan in the Asderote set. For standard skillet cooking, both sets provide the same essential sizes, ensuring you can handle most everyday meals with either option.
Which Cast Iron Set Fits You
You want maximum cooking versatility
The Asderote set includes a square grill pan and a cover that fits both the skillet and dutch oven. This six-piece collection lets you sear, grill, and braise without buying extra tools. The extra piece adds value if you cook diverse meals often. You get more utility from a single purchase, making it the better choice for flexible cooking needs.
You prefer lighter, easier storage
The Lodge set weighs 28 pounds, which is 4 pounds lighter than the Asderote option. It also has a smaller footprint, measuring 15 inches in length compared to 22.6 inches. If you have limited cabinet space or struggle with heavy pots, this five-piece set is easier to handle and store. You save weight and space without losing core functionality.
You need oven-safe durability
Asderote cookware is oven-safe up to 500°F. This high heat tolerance allows you to roast, bake, or broil safely at higher temperatures. While Lodge does not list a specific oven limit in the provided data, Asderote gives you a clear, high ceiling for heat. Choose this set if you frequently cook dishes that require high-heat oven finishing.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Asderote 6-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set | complete PFAS-free cast iron collections | Check price of Asderote 6-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set on Amazon |
| 2 | Lodge 5-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set | buyers wanting essential cast iron pieces | Check price of Lodge 5-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set on Amazon |
The products compared
Asderote 6-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set
Best for: complete PFAS-free cast iron collections
- Number of Pieces
- 6-Piece (what this guide is about)
- Body Material
- Cast iron
- Cooking Surface
- Pre-seasoned
- Oven Safe
- Up to 500°F
- Material Feature
- PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned
- Color
- Black
View on Amazon: Asderote 6-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set Affiliate link
This Asderote set includes six cast iron pieces, including skillets, a Dutch oven, and a griddle. It is pre-seasoned with natural vegetable oil and contains zero PFAS. The cookware is oven-safe up to 500°F and weighs 32 pounds. The stackable design helps save kitchen storage space. You will get even heat distribution and durable, nonstick surfaces for various cooking methods.
Pros
- Includes 6 pieces for versatile cooking
- Pre-seasoned with natural vegetable oil
- Oven-safe up to 500°F
- Zero PFAS, PFOA, or PTFE
- Stackable design saves storage space
Cons
- Heavy 32-pound total weight
- Requires hand washing and oiling to prevent rust
- Limited to 500°F oven safety
Good fit if
- You want a complete set with multiple pans
- You prefer PFAS-free cookware
- You have space for heavy, stackable items
Skip if
- You need lightweight cookware
- You want dishwasher-safe items
- You require oven safety above 500°F
Verdict: Asderote 6-Piece Cast Iron Set offers a comprehensive collection for those who value durability and chemical-free surfaces. It suits buyers who do not mind the weight and maintenance of traditional cast iron.
Lodge 5-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set
Best for: buyers wanting essential cast iron pieces
- Number of Pieces
- 5-Piece (what this guide is about)
- Body Material
- Cast Iron
- Cooking Surface
- Pre-seasoned
- Material Feature
- PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned, Non-Toxic
- Color
- Black
- Dimensions
- 15 × 14.2 × 7.9 inches
View on Amazon: Lodge 5-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set Affiliate link
This Lodge set includes an 8-inch skillet, 10.25-inch skillet, 10.5-inch griddle, and a 5-quart dutch oven with lid. The cast iron construction provides even heat distribution and retains warmth well. It is pre-seasoned with iron and oil, ensuring a PFAS-free surface. The pieces fit stovetops, ovens, and grills. You get a versatile indoor and outdoor cooking solution that is durable and easy to clean.
Pros
- Includes five essential pieces: two skillets, a griddle, and a dutch oven
- Pre-seasoned with iron and oil for a PFAS-free cooking surface
- Cast iron body ensures even heat distribution and retention
- Versatile design works on stovetops, in ovens, on grills, and over campfires
Cons
- Heavy build at 28 pounds makes handling difficult for some users
- Fewer pieces than the 6-piece alternative on this list
- Requires hand washing to maintain the seasoning layer
Good fit if
- You want a complete set of essential cast iron cookware
- You cook with both stovetops and outdoor heat sources
- You prefer PFAS-free, chemical-free cooking surfaces
Skip if
- You need lighter cookware for easy daily handling
- You want more variety with a 6-piece configuration
- You prefer non-stick surfaces that require no seasoning
Verdict: Lodge 5-Piece Cast Iron Set offers a solid foundation for cast iron cooking with five key pieces. It suits buyers who value durability and heat retention over lightweight convenience.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Asderote 6-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set | Lodge 5-Piece Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Cookware Set |
|---|---|---|
| Body Material | Cast iron | Cast Iron |
| Cooking Surface | Pre-seasoned | Pre-seasoned |
| Oven Safe | Up to 500°F | not stated |
| Number of Pieces | 6 | 5 |
| Material | Cast Iron | Cast Iron |
| Material Feature | PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned | PFAS-Free, Pre-Seasoned, Non-Toxic |
| Color | Black | Black |
| Use | Camping | not stated |
| Recommended Use | Grilling | not stated |
| Shape | Round | not stated |
| Dimensions | 22.6 × 12.8 × 6.3 inches | 15 × 14.2 × 7.9 inches |
| Weight | 32 pounds | 28 pounds |
| Size | 6 Piece | 5 Piece |
| Model | Skillet Set | Skillet Set |
Frequently asked questions
Is the 6-Piece Asderote set too heavy for daily use?
The Asderote 6-Piece Cast Iron Set weighs 32 pounds. This substantial weight provides excellent heat retention but may be challenging for some users to lift. You should consider your strength and kitchen storage space before purchasing this comprehensive collection.
What are the dimensions of the Lodge 5-Piece set?
The Lodge 5-Piece Skillet Set measures 15 inches in length, 14.2 inches in width, and 7.9 inches in height. These dimensions define the footprint of the five essential pieces included in this durable, pre-seasoned cast iron collection.
Does the Asderote set include a lid?
Yes, the Asderote 6-Piece Cast Iron Set includes a cover that fits both the skillet and dutch oven. This accessory allows you to braise or simmer liquids effectively, adding versatility to your cooking routine without needing separate lids.
Is cast iron PFAS-free in these sets?
Both the Asderote and Lodge sets are explicitly PFAS-free. They are made from pre-seasoned cast iron, which offers a natural non-stick surface. This material choice ensures you avoid synthetic coatings while enjoying durable, long-lasting cookware for various meals.
How much storage space does the 6-Piece set need?
The Asderote 6-Piece Set requires significant storage space due to its 32-pound weight and 22.6-inch length. You need a sturdy cabinet or shelf that can support the heavy cast iron pieces and accommodate the larger overall dimensions of the collection.
Can I use the Lodge set for grilling vegetables?
The Lodge 5-Piece set focuses on essential pieces like skillets and dutch ovens. While you can sear vegetables in a skillet, it lacks the dedicated square grill pan found in the six-piece Asderote set. Choose Lodge for classic stovetop and oven cooking.
What is the color of these cookware sets?
Both the Asderote and Lodge sets are black. This classic color is standard for pre-seasoned cast iron cookware. It provides a traditional aesthetic that complements most kitchen decors while indicating the natural seasoning layer on the cooking surfaces.
Which set is better for small kitchens?
The Lodge 5-Piece Set is better for small kitchens. It weighs 28 pounds and has a smaller footprint compared to the 32-pound, 22.6-inch long Asderote set. You save space by getting five essential pieces rather than six, including the larger grill pan.